ESIL Interest Group History of International Law

ESIL Interest Group History of International Law

Tuesday 2 April 2019

ARTICLE: Annabel BRETT, "The Subject of Sovereignty: Law, Politics and Moral Reasoning in Hugo Grotius" (Modern Intellectual History, 2019)

(image source: CUP)

Abstract:
Hugo Grotius’s account of sovereign power in De iure belli ac pacis occupies a contested place in recent genealogies of modern sovereignty. This article takes a fresh approach by arguing that Grotius’s legal arguments do not do their work alone. They function within a broader horizon of what he calls “morals,” a field of reasoning that has debts to scholastic moral theology and Aristotelian moral science. Grotius's conception of sovereignty represents a modulation between law and “morals,” which allows him both to separate his scientific jurisprudence from the science of politics and nevertheless to reply to the political scientists on their own ground. The context of “morals,” however, is not narrowly political but inter-political, generating a potential tension between popular aspirations to sovereignty and the international order. Grotius’s “moral” handling of the issue offers an invitation to reflect on our current preoccupation with much the same concerns.
More information with CUP.